Saturday
Mar262011
View of the Hebrews
Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews, published seven years before the Book of Mormon is thought to be source material for Joseph Smith's Book of Mormon.
LDS Historian and apostle Brigham Henry Roberts (B. H. Roberts) conducted an exhaustive comparison and analysis of these two books and concluded there is merit to this criticism.
Resources
LDS Historian and apostle Brigham Henry Roberts (B. H. Roberts) conducted an exhaustive comparison and analysis of these two books and concluded there is merit to this criticism.
-
Contrary to popular belief, the Book of Mormon was not the first to suggest that Jews are the ancestral origins of American Indians:
It is often represented by Mormon speakers and writers, that the Book of Mormon was first to represent the American Indians as descendants of the Hebrews: holding that the Book of Mormon is unique in this. The claim is sometimes still ignorantly made.
B.H. Roberts - Mormon Seventy and LDS church historian
Studies of the Book of Mormon, p.323 -
Many publications and materials predated the publication of the Book of Mormon:
For years such materials as were then found and discussed, theories as to the origin of the American Indians, including "the ten lost tribes" theory of Hebrew infusion into the American race, together with frequent mention of cultural traits favorable to this supposed Hebrew infusion-all this was matter of common speculation in the literature of America, before the publication of either Priest's American Antiquities or the Book of Mormon.
B.H. Roberts - Mormon Seventy and LDS church historian
Studies of the Book of Mormon, p.152 -
Joseph Smith had access to these early works:
It is altogether probable that these two books—Priest's Wonders of Nature and Providence, 1824; and Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews 1st edition 1823, and the 2nd edition 1825—were either possessed by Joseph Smith or certainly known by him, for they were surely available to him.
B.H. Roberts - Mormon Seventy and LDS church historian
Studies of the Book of Mormon, p.153 -
We know that Joseph Smith was familiar with View of the Hebrews as he quoted page 220 from it:
If such may have been the fact, that a part of the Ten Tribes came over to America, in the way we have supposed, leaving the cold regions of Assareth behind them in quest of a milder climate, it would be natural to look for tokens of the presence of Jews of some sort, along countries adjacent to the Atlantic. In order to this, we shall here make an extract from an able work: written exclusively on the subject of the Ten Tribes having come from Asia by the way of Bherings Strait, by the Rev. Ethan Smith, Pultney, Vt., who relates as follows:... -Smith's view of the Hebrews. Pg. 220.
The Parallels
A summary of B.H. Roberts comparison of View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon:| View of the Hebrews | Book of Mormon | |
| Published |
1823, first edition 1825, second edition |
1830, first edition |
| Location |
Vermont Poultney, Rutland County Note: Oliver Cowdery, one of the Book of Mormon witnesses, lived in Poultney when View of the Hebrews was published. |
Vermont Sharon, Windsor County Note: Windsor County is adjacent to Rutland County. |
| The destruction of Jerusalem | ||
| The scattering of Israel | ||
| The restoration of the Ten Tribes | ||
| Hebrews leave the Old World for the New World | ||
| Religion a motivating factor | ||
| Migrations a long journey | ||
| Encounter "seas" of "many waters" | ||
| The Americas an uninhabited land | ||
| Settlers journey northward | ||
| Encounter a valley of a great river | ||
| A unity of race (Hebrew) settle the land and are the ancestral origin of American Indians | ||
| Hebrew the origin of Indian language | ||
| Egyptian hieroglyphics | ||
| Lost Indian records | A set of "yellow leaves" buried in Indian hill. Roberts noted the "leaves" may be gold. |
Joseph Smith claims the Book of Mormon is a translation of ancient Indian records from gold plates buried in a hill. |
| Breastplate, Urim & Thummin | ||
| Prophets, spiritually gifted men transmit generational records | ||
| The Gospel preached in the Americas | ||
| Quotes whole chapters of Isaiah | ||
| Messiah visits the Americas | Quetzalcoatl, the white bearded "Mexican Messiah" |
|
| Good and bad are a necessary opposition | ||
| Generosity encouraged and pride denounced | ||
| Polygamy denounced | ||
| Idolatry and human sacrifice | ||
| Sacred towers and high places | ||
| Hebrews divide into two classes, civilized and barbarous | ||
| Civilized thrive in art, written language, metallurgy, navigation | ||
| Government changes from monarchy to republic | ||
| Civil and ecclesiastical power is united in the same person | ||
| Long wars break out between the civilized and barbarous | ||
| Extensive military fortifications, observations, "watch towers" | ||
| Barbarous exterminate the civilized | ||
| Discusses the United States | ||
| Ethan/Ether | Roberts noted: "Ethan is prominently connected with the recording of the matter in the one case, and Ether in the other." | |
| Source: B.H. Roberts, Studies of the Book of Mormon, p.240-242,324-344 | ||
-
Roberts noted the abundance of parallels
Did Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews furnish structural material for Joseph Smith's Book of Mormon? It has been pointed out in these pages that there are many things in the former book that might well have suggested many major things in the other. Not a few things merely, one or two, or half dozen, but many; and it is this fact of many things of similarity and the cumulative force of them that makes them so serious a menace to Joseph Smith's story of the Book of Mormon's origin.
B.H. Roberts - Mormon Seventy and LDS church historian
Studies of the Book of Mormon, p.240 - See also Did Joseph Smith author the Book of Mormon?
Resources
- View of the Hebrews, 1823 First Edition
- View of the Hebrews, 1823 First Edition [PDF]
- View of the Hebrews, 1825 Second Edition
-
Studies of the Book of Mormon [Amazon]
Note: no online sources are available for this reference.
Recommend 